Welcome to Sal and Carmine Pizza
At Sal and Carmine Pizza, we celebrate the essence of authentic Italian pizza right in the heart of New York City's Upper West Side. Our story began with a passion for creating mouthwatering pies using high-quality ingredients, from fresh mozzarella to rich tomato sauce. Known for its casual vibe and outstanding service focused solely on efficiency, we prioritize flavor above all. Our menu features a range of options, including vegetarian delights and signature creations like the Upside Down Margherita. Patrons rave about our consistently delicious offerings, ensuring that every visit is a pizza lover’s dream come true. Join us for a slice!
Sal and Carmine Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
By far the best pizza on the Upper West Side and is in the top 2 in NYC. Service is focused on making pizza efficiency not banter. Atmosphere is not important. Its all about the pizza!
I dont write reviews like never but i had to this time. This pizza is SOOOO AMAZING. I am so funny about pizza. I would say I love Pastys but this is too good not to put on the top tiers of must eats. I had their Red Peppers and Sauteed ...
Sal Carmine Pizza always hits the spot! To me, their pizza is underrated which I dont mind because that means fewer people haha. Compared to all of the pizzerias in the neighborhood that sell street pizza they have the best. The ...
I dont even know how to describe this place without saying its the best. Whenever i think of NY pizza I think of this place. I live in Jersey Ive been here about 2 times so far early September and early December. First time I went with ...
Sal and Carmines on the Upper West Side is a true gem for pizza lovers! I ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza, and it was absolutely delicious. The pizza was generously topped with a rich, flavorful sauce that perfectly complemented the ...
I love this place. I take friends who are visiting NYC for this authentic New York style pizza. The owner is super nice. I come here a lot. The atmosphere isnt anything special, its basically a typical pizza joint.
Objectively the best pizza in the world by far. Sals does it the right way, proper newyork Italian slice since the 1950s. I look forward to it every time.
phone doesnt eat first here!!!!! pizza is SO good. pepperoni was a little oily but thats pepperoni. please excuse my friends psychotic pizza eating technique i was also very disturbed by it.
Location
-
2671 Broadway, New York, NY 10025 Hotline: (212) 663-7651
If you're searching for a slice of genuine New York pizza, Sal and Carmine Pizza is a destination that promises to exceed your expectations. Nestled at 2671 Broadway, New York, NY 10025, this Italian pizzeria has made a name for itself on the Upper West Side, celebrated for its exceptional quality and rich flavors.
From the moment you step in—or rather, order in—Sal and Carmine’s efficiency shines. As customers have noted, the focus here is firmly on delivering remarkable pizza. With options for delivery, takeout, and even reservations, they ensure that enjoying exquisite pizza is accessible to all. The casual atmosphere paired with quiet dining makes it an ideal spot for families, groups, or those seeking a peaceful meal.
- What to Expect:
- A plethora of vegetarian options, perfect for diverse dietary preferences.
- Convenient payment methods including Android Pay, Apple Pay, and credit card acceptance.
- Ample amenities such as free Wi-Fi, outdoor seating, and even bike parking!
- Plastic-free packaging reflecting a commitment to sustainability.
The star of the show, of course, is the pizza itself. Take, for instance, the Medium Cheese Pizza—a lovely 16-inch masterpiece for just $21.00, or the generous Large Cheese Pizza at $27.00, which promises to leave you with leftovers, if you're lucky! Craving something special? Try the Upsidedown Margherita Pizza, featuring cheese on the bottom and sauce dollops on top; it's a delightful twist that showcases their creativity and skill.
Customer reviews echo the restaurant's acclaim, with one patron declaring it "the best pizza on the Upper West Side" and others lauding the quality and flavor that stands up against pizzerias across all of NYC. The consensus? Sal and Carmine Pizza isn't just another spot; it’s a place where the magic of pizza-making shines.
Whether you're enjoying a leisurely lunch, dining with friends, or taking advantage of their catering service, Sal and Carmine Pizza excels in delivering a memorable experience. The rich, flavorful sauces, perfectly baked crusts, and generous toppings create a combination that's hard to resist. When all is said and done, every slice is a reminder why this pizzeria has earned its place in the hearts of locals and visitors alike.
In conclusion, if you're ever on the Upper West Side, make sure to stop by Sal and Carmine Pizza. With its irresistible offerings and commitment to quality, it's a culinary destination that should not be missed.
